9 min read
Ann Patchett knew we would want to know about the horse. The mare stares, impossibly, out at the reader from a grassy plain on an ink-blue night in Wyoming, her reins skimming the ground, hooves eternally fixed in place upon the cover of Patchett’s latest novel, Whistler. That’s the horse’s name: Whistler. She plays only a small role in the book that bears her name and likeness, yet it’s an essential role—and one that encapsulates Patchett’s no-frills skill for revealing the exceptional in what might otherwise be overlooked.
For this image of Whistler—who will meet the gaze of readers around the world this week as the book hits shelves—Patchett worked with her dear friend and artist Noah Saterstrom, who also painted the cover for Patchett’s Pulitzer Prize finalist The Dutch House. Per her vision, Patchett instructed Saterstrom that she wanted a painting of a horse—“a beautiful horse, chestnut color with a white blaze and two white stockings,” as Patchett writes in the novel—looking out at the viewer. Saterstrom pointed out that this was a nonstarter: Horses’ eyes are on the side of their heads. Patchett shrugged. “Figure it out,” she told Saterstrom.
Saterstrom presented her with one option: the horse positioned to its side, gazing out with one all-seeing eye. “I was like, ‘No, no,’” Patchett says. “‘No horse’s ass. I want the horse straight!’ And then he would paint it, and I was like, ‘What is this? An English saddle? No, they’re in Wyoming! Give me a Western saddle! Put the reins on the ground. The mountains are too big. Bring the mountains down!’ It’s hilarious. This is just how Noah and I work when we work on something together.”
But the end result was perfect: Whistler, her white blaze majestic beneath her perked ears, beckons to the reader from beneath the star-flecked sky. “I know that people are reading this book thinking, ‘Why is there a horse on the cover?’” Patchett says. “‘Why is this book called Whistler? Who’s the horse? Why does that look like the West? This is a New York story. Wait, when are we getting to the horse?’”
When Whistler finally arrives, it is in the middle of a different story entirely. Patchett’s Whistler focuses on the relationship between English teacher Daphne Fuller and her former stepfather, editor Eddie Triplett, who reappears unexpectedly in Daphne’s life during a chance encounter at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Now middle-aged herself, Daphne has not seen Eddie since she was a child, but he still thinks of her as his daughter, and the two discover that the familiarity between them has not waned with time. They share the intimacy of renewed friendship, bolstered by small revelations: As it turns out, Eddie is gay, and his relationship with Daphne’s mother broke down, in part, because he could not deny that truth. (As he explains to Daphne midway through the novel, “No one would say such a thing today, but there was a time when it did not feel like lunacy to want what the majority of the human population had. Your mother’s deal was that I had to give up Skip [Eddie’s partner] and give up being gay. I know it sounds terrible now, but she didn’t know any better. I’m the one who should have known better.”) Being alongside Eddie as an adult gives Daphne a shifted perspective on both her deceased biological father and her still-living mother, who up to this point “had annoyed me deeply throughout most of my life,” as she narrates in the book. But it also provides her the opportunity to appreciate what Patchett refers to as the “romance” of their friendship.
“Friendship can be so romantic, in such a happy, happy way,” the author says. She dedicated Whistler to her late friend Jim Fox, who used to work as legal counsel at HarperCollins and died in 2024, to underscore this idea. “I thought, I want to take all the love that I had for Jim and that Jim had for me and put it in a book that is not about Jim, is not about me, is not about our relationship,” she continues. “But people keep saying, ‘This book feels so autobiographical. It feels so true.’ And it is true, in the nature of the love.”
Patchett, 62, has a long-established penchant for recognizing the “nature of love” in everyday circumstances, while maintaining a wry lens on the humor and contradictions of those same circumstances. “The idea that romance—let’s go to a wedding, let’s dance, let’s walk home through New York City—that that’s something that needs to only happen between you and your romantic partner is really limiting,” she says. “Because it’s a joy, and it’s a huge joy when you know you are never going to fall in love and have sex. That’s not in the cards. Totally not on the table. It’s just fantastic. And I was so happy to get that feeling into a book.”
“Friendship can be so romantic, in such a happy, happy way.”
In the scene to which Patchett is referring here, Daphne and Eddie crash a wedding together, and as they drunkenly stroll outside the Plaza afterwards, Daphne asks if Eddie remembers a story he once told her as a child, when the two of them had endured a car accident and were awaiting rescue. Here, at last, Whistler makes her appearance. In Eddie’s telling, Whistler is a mare who belonged to a Wyoming rancher named Mary Carter, who fell off the horse’s back during a bad storm. When the lightning scares Whistler away, Mary is certain she will die alone in the grass. Days pass; she sees visions of her deceased loved ones: her son, her dog, her childhood best friend. They sit with her as she fades—but, ultimately, they remind her of Whistler’s namesake, the horse’s unique talent for coming when called upon. Weakly, Mary whistles, and Whistler comes back for her. And so it is with Eddie and Daphne, who together illuminate how people can choose to return to one another—and to themselves—again and again throughout their lives.
Like this story Eddie tells Daphne in their overturned car, Whistler itself is a straightforwardly good-hearted tale, made all the more remarkable for the courage of these qualities. Over the years, numerous readers and interviewers have asked Patchett why she writes books that so deeply emphasize kindness, books Patchett herself has referred to as “good, smart literary fiction that will not crush people’s souls.” In an era of buzzy sad-girl lit and weird-girl lit and ragebait lit, the PEN/Faulkner Award winner writes literary masterworks about “people who are not perfect, trying their best and showing up for each other.” They’re not simple books—please, don’t call them simple—but they are clear in their purpose.
As the owner of the beloved bookstore Parnassus Books in her hometown of Nashville, Patchett “can see the playing field” of publishing “clearly,” she says. These days, she reads almost nothing except for upcoming fiction and nonfiction; she knows what stories are being put on shelves on a weekly basis. “There are such great minds and such great talents who are bringing us such hard stories, and I feel like that’s important—and it’s covered,” she explains. “They’ve done the work, and I don’t need to do the work….But I feel like the kind of stuff that I write, there needs to be more of that.”
She continues, “And it is how I live my life. I can watch the news; I can read the paper; I can know that terrible things are happening everywhere. But in my life, everybody’s so nice. In the bookstore, in my house, in my neighborhood, in the grocery store, people are kind to one another. I know that part of it is that these are my eyes, and this is the way I see the world, and the more you see it, the more it reflects back. It becomes self-selecting. I’m not seeing horror in my everyday life. I’m reading it. I know it’s there. But it feels very realistic to write stories about people being kind.”
“It feels very realistic to write stories about people being kind.”
That approach to kindness extends to how she treats the art of literary citizenship itself. As an author and bookseller, Patchett frequently receives praise and recognition for her broader efforts in the bookish landscape: Just this year, she was honored with the PEN/Audible Literary Service Award for “her dedication to independent bookselling and nurturing a vibrant literary community,” as well as for speaking out against book banning. But Patchett tells me, only half-joking, that she should have received the award for frequently saving her peers in publishing from disaster. Sometimes, when she receives an advance copy of a book featuring what she considers “a really bad cover,” she’ll call the title’s editor to convey her concerns as a bookseller—and on multiple occasions, the editorial team has gone back and changed the design. Similarly, she’ll flag errors in other authors’ texts as she stumbles upon them: Most recently, she found a “mistake, not a typo” in a hugely anticipated work of literary fiction, written by a friend. “I wrote to her editor, and I was like, ‘Oh, it’s a galley—I’m sure 100 people have already written to you,’” Patchett says. They hadn’t. Five minutes later, Patchett says, the author herself emailed Patchett directly. “She was like, ‘Oh my God. I’m trying not to throw up. I cannot believe that—it was something from a previous draft that didn’t get updated.’”
As Patchett puts it, “You’ve got to have your eye on the sparrow. And so when people say, ‘You’re such a good literary citizen,’ that’s what I think of: the minutiae of looking out for one’s brothers and sisters.”
It was her “favorite writing teacher,” the late novelist Allan Gurganus, who first taught Patchett about the importance of this attention to detail. When Patchett sold her debut novel, The Patron Saint of Liars, back in the early ’90s, Gurganus told her not to assume that everyone else would operate with her innate precision. “Allan said, ‘This is your name on the book,’” Patchett says. “‘If there’s a typo, people will assume it is you. If the paper quality is poor, if the typeface is too small, if the jacket is ugly, whatever it is, it’s all 100 percent on you, and you have to steer the ship.’ He said, ‘It’s their job, but it’s your life.’ And I just carried that through my whole career.”
“Anger, rage, disgust, they’re low-hanging fruit. But to take a minute and say something good—and to see the good thing that is there—takes more effort.”
Patchett applies a similar sense of dutiful-but-earnest care to how she interacts with the world around her, and how she then conveys the world in her writing. “Somebody said something so fascinating to me recently,” she reflects. “They said, ‘Anger, rage, disgust, they’re low-hanging fruit. But to take a minute and say something good—and to see the good thing that is there—takes more effort.’”
That effort has ripple effects, she believes. It certainly did in the case of the fictional Daphne, a character who is, of course, inspired by many real middle-aged women Patchett has known (and been) over the years. “I do believe that if a person—and let’s say a child—has one person in their life who really sees them, connects with them, is interested, finds them interesting…that can be enough to set you on the good track for life,” she says. In the case of Daphne, that person is Eddie. Like Whistler, Daphne saved Eddie’s life all those years ago, when she ventured out from their car wreck to find help in the surrounding woods. And, like Whistler, Eddie returns to Daphne years later, when she needs him most.
“It’s very touching,” Patchett says, without so much as a flicker of self-consciousness. She is proud to write about what touches her. She is proud to write about kindness, about love. And she is proud to deal in stories about these things—effort, kindness, love—for a living.
So it should not come as a surprise that, as our conversation nears its end, she can’t resist doing a bit of bookselling. “Okay, I’m going to tell you one more thing,” she says, almost conspiratorially. “2026 is the best year for fiction I’ve seen since I opened a bookstore 15 years ago. Amazing, amazing books this year. The best book is coming out in October. Yiyun Li’s Music Against the Night.” She spells out the name—Y-I-Y-U-N-L-I—for me. “Go get yourself a galley,” she concludes.
I do as instructed: I request a galley from the publisher. I peer closely at the book’s cover. Like Whistler, Music Against the Night is adorned with a painting on its jacket, though, unlike Whistler, the cover does not feature a horse but instead a dock, ships, a moody sunset, a cluster of three people in 18th-century garb. They aren’t looking at me as Whistler did; they gaze out upon the still water, its surface a mirror of the clouds above. I want to know about these people, the way I wanted to know about the horse. This is what Patchett seems to recognize about her readers so well: Deep down, all of us want to know.
This, too, I think, is the “nature of love.” In this era of unrelenting onslaught, of constant content, perhaps it is a gift just to give our attention. I am thankful that—today, always—I still want to know.
